Back on October 21st, Electronic Arts formally announced its intention to shutter BioWare. Ironically, the move was likely motivated by the desire to use funding previously allocated to BioWare on Star Wars Battlefront 3. A long time ago, in a game industry far far removed from this one, BioWare jumpstarted both its own fortunes as well that of a Star Wars franchise ailing from mixed response to the prequel trilogy with a little game called Star Wars: Knights of the Old Republic. Back in 2019, gaming journalist Alex Kane recounted this game’s story in a Boss Fight book.

As far as the Boss Fight format goes, Kane’s tome is a relatively generic one. It’s quite short, only about a hundred pages long, and mainly just tells the story of the game’s production. To be entirely frank, the book’s not really that interesting, the timing of when I read it was mainly fortuitous because every so often Kane gets into snippets that rather understate just what Star Wars: Knights of the Old Republic did, not just for BioWare, not just for Star Wars, but for the gaming industry as a whole.

To put it simply, Star Wars: Knights of the Old Republic was the first truly cinematic game done in the role-playing style. It was also, crucially, the first console game done using a CRPG based combat system. Where previous BioWare joints like Baldur’s Gate were unavoidably linked to a point-and-click interface, Star Wars: Knights of the Old Republic was intended as a killer app for the original Xbox, not exactly the console of choice for pen-and-paper roleplaying nerds. Consequently, Star Wars: Knights of the Old Republic had to look and feel like an action game even if it was technically turn-based.

And that’s exactly what BioWare did, Star Wars: Knights of the Old Republic is, thanks in part to directives insisted on by Lucasarts, cinematic. It is fully voice-acted. And the writing even managed the incredible feat of pulling off a plot twist on the level of Luke, I am your father. I won’t spoil that twist, even if Kane does it immediately and without warning, because in all fairness anyone reading the book probably already knows what the twist is. Star Wars: Knights of the Old Republic achieved the very rare feat of delivering something that all Star Wars fans liked, even impressing journalists who were mostly indifferent to the franchise.

Kane tells this story but offers frustratingly little perspective. While I was a little harsh on the Dragon Age II Boss Fight book, it’s actually largely thanks to it that I was able to fill in the blanks myself and get some idea as to what the BioWare corporate culture was like and how the Star Wars: Knights of the Old Republic team several years earlier were able to pull the project together. The Goldeneye and Majora’s Mask books were also instructive in regard to the topics like throwing game engines together on a deadline and having to really double down on the first idea they came up with just because there wasn’t time to switch gears and do another one.

The Star Wars legacy that did so much to give Star Wars: Knights of the Old Republic its gravitas was also BioWare’s big weakness since, of course, they only had temporary access to the license. And while BioWare in the years to come responded by creating their own franchises, Dragon’s Age and Mass Effect, the increasingly cinematic expectations of those games were all working off of the template originally designed for a Star Wars game. Today, that need for budget hasn’t just doomed BioWare, it’s created increasingly onerous restrictions on nearly every major release.

It’s funny to even think about Star Wars: Knights of the Old Republic in a retro context. Despite its own emphasis on playability first, the game ultimately led to game releases seeming more and more like events rather than, well, games. Kane’s story of how Ed Asner joined the voice cast, recounted with wonder and incredulity by voice-over director Darragh O’Farrell, is fascinating because what might have seemed absurd at the time now seems like a perfectly reasonable expectation.

Similarly, having been shut out of the Baldur’s Gate revival, BioWare’s shuttering comes as another studio, Mad Head Games, is still finishing a Star Wars: Knights of the Old Republic remake project that got started all the way back in 2021. I can’t hold it against Kane for not discussing this, since it hadn’t happened yet when he wrote the book. But with so many potentially interesting angles for a deep dive only briefly touched on, I must confess to being disappointed that he only ever really scratches the surface here.